1.State Key Laboratory of Polymer Physics and Chemistry, Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun 130022, China
[ "Wen-Sheng Xu received his Ph.D. degree from Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2012. From 2013 to 2018, he was a postdoctoral scholar first with Professor Karl F. Freed at the University of Chicago and then with Dr. Yangyang Wang at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. He is currently a professor in the State Key Laboratory of Polymer Physics and Chemistry at Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, where he has been a faculty member since 2019. His research group utilizes theoretical methods and computer simulations to investigate the dynamics of noncrystalline polymer materials\t\t\t\t\t\t" ]
[ "Zhao-Yan Sun received her Ph.D. degree from Jilin University in 2001. She was a postdoctoral fellow at University of Dortmund from 2001 to 2002. Since 2003, she has been a faculty member in the State Key Laboratory of Polymer Physics and Chemistry at Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, initially as an assistant professor and then an associate professor, before becoming a full professor in 2010. She was awarded the Young Chemistry Award of the Chinese Chemical Society in 2005. Her research group focuses on the structure and dynamics of polymers and nanocomposites and the development of computer simulation methods\t\t\t\t\t\t" ]
Scan for full text
Wen-Sheng Xu, Zhao-Yan Sun. A Thermodynamic Perspective on Polymer Glass Formation. [J]. Chinese Journal of Polymer Science 41(9):1329-1341(2023)
Wen-Sheng Xu, Zhao-Yan Sun. A Thermodynamic Perspective on Polymer Glass Formation. [J]. Chinese Journal of Polymer Science 41(9):1329-1341(2023) DOI: 10.1007/s10118-023-2951-1.
The present paper provides an overview of the thermodynamic models of glass formation, with an emphasis on the advances that attempt to bring together some of the seemingly disparate thermodynamic viewpoints on glass formation.
The dynamics of polymeric and other glass-forming liquids dramatically slows down upon cooling toward the glass transition temperature without any obvious significant change in their static structure. A quantitative understanding of this extraordinary dynamic slowdown remains one of the most significant challenges in condensed matter physics. Historically, extensive efforts have been devoted to explaining the dynamics of glass-forming liquids in terms of thermodynamic properties, leading to a number of semi-empirical models emphasizing distinct thermodynamic properties. Here, a thermodynamic perspective is provided on the glass formation of polymeric and other materials. We begin with an overview of the thermodynamic models of glass formation, including the intuitively appealing “free volume” models, enthalpy models originally emphasized by Goldstein and later by others, and the highly influential configurational entropy-based models. The review of these models is followed by a discussion of the advances that attempt to bring together some of the seemingly disparate thermodynamic viewpoints on glass formation by revealing a close interrelation between thermodynamic properties. We conclude this review with remarks on several key topics in this field, along with our viewpoint for future work.
Glass formationEntropyFree volumeEnthalpy
Debenedetti,P.G.;Stillinger,F.H.Supercooledliquidsandtheglasstransition.Nature2001,410,259−267..
Ediger,M.D.;Angell,C.A.;Nagel,S.R.Supercooledliquidsandglasses.J. Phys. Chem.1996,100,13200−13212..
Berthier,L.;Biroli,G.Theoreticalperspectiveontheglasstransitionandamorphousmaterials.Rev. Mod. Phys.2011,83,587−645..
Ediger,M.D.;Harrowell,P.Perspective:supercooledliquidsandglasses.J. Chem. Phys.2012,137,080901..
Biroli,G.;Garrahan,J.P.Perspective:theglasstransition.J. Chem. Phys.2013,138,12A301..
Debenedetti,P.G.;Stillinger,F.H.Glasstransitionthermodynamicsandkinetics.Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys.2013,4,263−285..
Parry,B.;Surovtsev,I.;Cabeen,M.;O’Hern,C.;Dufresne,E.;Jacobs-Wagner,C.Thebacterialcytoplasmhasglass-likepropertiesandisfluidizedbymetabolicactivity.Cell2014,156,183−194..
Roos,Y.H.Glasstransitiontemperatureanditsrelevanceinfoodprocessing.Annu. Rev. Food Sci. Technol.2010,1,469−496..
Xu,Z.;Dai,X.;Bu,X.;Yang,Y.;Zhang,X.;Man,X.;Zhang,X.;Doi,M.;Yan,L.T.Enhancedheterogeneousdiffusionofnanoparticlesinsemiflexiblenetworks.ACS Nano2021,15,4608−4616..
Dai,X.;Zhang,X.;Gao,L.;Xu,Z.;Yan,L.T.Topologymediatestransportofnanoparticlesinmacromolecularnetworks.Nat. Commun.2022,13,4094..
Dai,X.;Zhu,Z.;Li,Y.;Yang,B.;Xu,J.F.;Dong,Y.;Zhou,X.;Yan,L.-T.;Liu,D.“Shutter”effectsenhanceproteindiffusionindynamicandrigidmolecularnetworks.J. Am. Chem. Soc.2022,144,19017−19025..
DiMarzio,E.A.Equilibriumtheoryofglasses.Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.1981,371,1−20..
Smallenburg,F.;Sciortino,F.Liquidsmorestablethancrystalsinparticleswithlimitedvalenceandflexiblebonds.Nat. Phys.2013,9,554−558..
Zhang,G.;Stillinger,F.H.;Torquato,S.Theperfectglassparadigm:disorderedhyperuniformglassesdowntoabsoluteZero.Sci. Rep.2016,6,36963..
Ingebrigtsen,T.S.;Dyre,J.C.;Schrøder,T.B.;Royall,C.P.Crystallizationinstabilityinglass-formingmixtures.Phys. Rev. X2019,9,031016..
Roland,C.M.;Hensel-Bielowka,S.;Paluch,M.;Casalini,R.Supercooleddynamicsofglass-formingliquidsandpolymersunderhydrostaticpressure.Rep. Prog. Phys.2005,68,1405−1478..
Roland,C.M.Relaxationphenomenainvitrifyingpolymersandmolecularliquids.Macromolecules2010,43,7875−7890..
Cangialosi,D.Dynamicsandthermodynamicsofpolymerglasses.J. Phys.: Condens. Matter2014,26,153101..
Napolitano,S.;Glynos,E.;Tito,N.B.Glasstransitionofpolymersinbulk,confinedgeometries,andnearinterfaces.Rep. Prog. Phys.2017,80,036602..
McKenna,G.B.;Simon,S.L.50thAnniversaryperspective:challengesinthedynamicsandkineticsofglass-formingPolymers.Macromolecules2017,50,6333−6361..
Dudowicz,J.;Freed,K.F.;Douglas,J.F.Generalizedentropytheoryofpolymerglassformation.Adv. Chem. Phys.2008,137,125−222..
Xu,W.-S.;Douglas,J.F.;Sun,Z.Y.Polymerglassformation:roleofactivationfreeenergy,configurationalentropy,andcollectivemotion.Macromolecules2021,54,3001−3033..
Götze,W.inComplex Dynamics of Glass-Forming Liquids: A Mode-Coupling Theory.OxfordUniversityPress,Oxford,2008..
PazmiñoBetancourt,B.A.;Hanakata,P.Z.;Starr,F.W.;Douglas,J.F.Quantitativerelationsbetweencooperativemotion,emergentelasticity,andfreevolumeinmodelglass-formingpolymermaterials.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.2015,112,2966−2971..
Goldstein,M.Somethermodynamicaspectsoftheglasstransition:freevolume,entropy,andenthalpytheories.J. Chem. Phys.1963,39,3369−3374..
Caruthers,J.M.;Medvedev,G.A.Quantitativemodelofsuper-Arrhenianbehavioringlassformingmaterials.Phys. Rev. Materials2018,2,055604..
Medvedev,G.A.;Caruthers,J.M.Aquantitativemodelofsuper-Arrhenianbehavioringlass-formingpolymers.Macromolecules2019,52,1424−1439..
Zhao,X.;Simon,S.L.Amodel-freeanalysisofconfigurationalpropertiestoreducethetemperature-andpressure-dependentsegmentalrelaxationtimesofpolymers.J. Chem. Phys.2020,152,044901..
Kauzmann,W.Thenatureoftheglassystateandthebehaviorofliquidsatlowtemperatures.Chem. Rev.1948,43,219−256..
Xu,X.;Douglas,J.F.;Xu,W.S.Thermodynamic–dynamicinterrelationsinglass-formingpolymerfluids.Macromolecules2022,55,8699−8722..
Lucretius,InGreat Books of the Western World.Hutchins,R.M.,Ed.;EncyclopaediaBritannica,Inc.:Chicago,1952;BookI..
Robertson,R.E.Theoryfortheplasticityofglassypolymers.J. Chem. Phys.1966,44,3950−3956..
Batschinski,A.J.UntersuchungenüberdieinnereReibungderFlüssigkeiten.Z. Phys. Chem.1913,84U,643−706..
Hildebrand,J.H.inViscosity and Diffusivity: A Predictive Treatment.Wiley,NewYork,1977..
Hildebrand,J.H.;Lamoreaux,R.H.Fluidity:ageneraltheory.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.1972,69,3428−3431..
Doolittle,A.K.StudiesinNewtonianflow.I.Thedependenceoftheviscosityofliquidsontemperature.J. Appl. Phys.1951,22,1031−1035..
FoxJr.,T.G.;Flory,P.J.Second-ordertransitiontemperaturesandrelatedpropertiesofpolystyrene.I.Influenceofmolecularweight.J. Appl. Phys.1950,21,581−591..
Vogel,H.Thelawoftherelationshipbetweenviscosityofliquidsandthetemperature.Phys. Z.1921,22,645−646..
Fulcher,G.S.Analysisofrecentmeasurementsoftheviscosityofglasses.J. Am. Ceram. Soc.1925,8,339−355..
Tammann,G.;Hesse,W.DieAbhängigkeitderviscositätvondertemperaturbieunterkühltenflüssigkeiten.Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem.1926,156,245−257..
Ferry,J.D.inViscoelastic Properties of Polymers.Wiley,NewYork,1980..
Williams,M.L.;Landel,R.F.;Ferry,J.D.Thetemperaturedependenceofrelaxationmechanismsinamorphouspolymersandotherglass-formingliquids.J. Am. Chem. Soc.1955,77,3701−3707..
White,R.P.;Lipson,J.E.G.Polymerfreevolumeanditsconnectiontotheglasstransition.Macromolecules2016,49,3987−4007..
White,R.P.;Lipson,J.E.G.ExplainingtheT,V-dependentdynamicsofglassformingliquids:Thecooperativefreevolumemodeltestedagainstnewsimulationresults.J. Chem. Phys.2017,147,184503..
White,R.P.;Lipson,J.E.G.Pressure-dependentdynamicsofpolymermeltsfromArrheniustonon-Arrhenius:thecooperativefreevolumerateequationtestedagainstsimulationdata.Macromolecules2018,51,4896−4909..
White,R.P.;Lipson,J.E.G.Connectingpressure-dependentdynamicstodynamicsunderconfinement:thecooperativefreevolumemodelappliedtopoly(4-chlorostyrene)bulkandthinfilms.Macromolecules2018,51,7924−7941..
Debot,A.;White,R.P.;Lipson,J.E.G.;Napolitano,S.Experimentaltestofthecooperativefreevolumeratemodelunder1Dconfinement:theinterplayoffreevolume,temperature,andpolymerfilmthicknessindrivingsegmentalmobility.ACS Macro Lett.2019,8,41−45..
Xu,W.S.;Douglas,J.F.;Xia,W.;Xu,X.Understandingactivationvolumeinglass-formingpolymermeltsviageneralizedentropytheory.Macromolecules2020,53,7239−7252..
Xu,W.S.;Douglas,J.F.;Freed,K.F.Entropytheoryofpolymerglass-formationinvariablespatialdimension.Adv. Chem. Phys.2016,161,443−497..
Xu,W.-S.;Douglas,J.F.;Xu,X.Roleofcohesiveenergyinglassformationofpolymerswithandwithoutbendingconstraints.Macromolecules2020,53,9678−9697..
Floudas,G.;Paluch,M.;Grzybowski,A.;Ngai,K.L.inMolecular Dynamics of Glass-Forming Systems: Effects of Pressure.1stEd.;Springer-Verlag:Berlin,2010..
Sanchez,I.C.Dimensionlessthermodynamics:anewparadigmforliquidstateproperties.J. Phys. Chem. B2014,118,9386−9397..
Simha,R.;Boyer,R.F.Onageneralrelationinvolvingtheglasstemperatureandcoefficientsofexpansionofpolymers.J. Chem. Phys.1962,37,1003−1007..
Foreman,K.W.;Freed,K.F.Latticeclustertheoryofmulticomponentpolymersystems:chainsemiflexibilityandspecificinteractions.Adv. Chem. Phys.1998,103,335−390..
Xu,W.S.;Freed,K.F.Latticeclustertheoryforpolymermeltswithspecificinteractions.J. Chem. Phys.2014,141,044909..
Adam,G.;Gibbs,J.H.OnthetemperaturedependenceofcooperativerelaxationPropertiesinglass-formingLiquids.J. Chem. Phys.1965,43,139−146..
Stukalin,E.B.;Douglas,J.F.;Freed,K.F.Applicationoftheentropytheoryofglassformationtopoly(α-olefins).J. Chem. Phys.2009,131,114905..
Yang,Z.;Xu,X.;Xu,W.S.Influenceofionicinteractionstrengthonglassformationofanion-containingpolymermelt.Macromolecules2021,54,9587−9601..
Starr,F.W.;Sastry,S.;Douglas,J.F.;Glotzer,S.C.Whatdowelearnfromthelocalgeometryofglass-formingliquids?Phys. Rev. Lett.2002,89,125501..
Hanakata,P.Z.;Douglas,J.F.;Starr,F.W.Localvariationoffragilityandglasstransitiontemperatureofultra-thinsupportedpolymerfilms.J. Chem. Phys.2012,137,244901..
Zhang,W.;Starr,F.W.;Douglas,J.F.Reconcilingcomputationalandexperimentaltrendsinthetemperaturedependenceoftheinterfacialmobilityofpolymerfilms.J. Chem. Phys.2020,152,124703..
Douglas,J.F.;PazminoBetancourt,B.A.;Tong,X.;Zhang,H.Localizationmodeldescriptionofdiffusionandstructuralrelaxationinglass-formingCu-Zralloys.J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp.2016,054048,.
Zhang,H.;Wang,X.;Douglas,J.F.LocalizationmodeldescriptionofdiffusionandstructuralrelaxationinsuperioniccrystallineUO2.J. Chem. Phys.2019,151,071101..
Simmons,D.S.;Cicerone,M.T.;Zhong,Q.;Tyagi,M.;Douglas,J.F.Generalizedlocalizationmodelofrelaxationinglass-formingliquids.Soft Matter2012,8,11455−11461..
Sutherland,W.XXXVI.Anewperiodicpropertyoftheelements.London, Edinburgh Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.1890,30,318−323..
Sutherland,W.V.Akinetictheoryofsolids,withanExperimentalIntroduction.London, Edinburgh Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.1891,32,31−43..
Sutherland,W.XXIX.Akinetictheoryofsolids,withanexperimentalintroduction.London, Edinburgh Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.1891,32,215−225..
Sutherland,W.LXIII.Akinetictheoryofsolids,withanexperimentalintroduction.London, Edinburgh Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.1891,32,524−553..
Larini,L.;Ottochian,A.;DeMichele,C.;Leporini,D.Universalscalingbetweenstructuralrelaxationandvibrationaldynamicsinglass-formingliquidsandpolymers.Nat. Phys.2008,4,42−45..
Davies,R.O.;Jones,G.O.Theirreversibleapproachtoequilibriuminglasses.Proc. R. Soc. A1953,217,26−42..
Goldstein,M.Onthetemperaturedependenceofcooperativerelaxationpropertiesinglass-formingliquids—commentonapaperbyAdamandGibbs.J. Chem. Phys.1965,43,1852−1853..
Simon,F.ÜberdenZustandderunterkühltenFlüssigkeitenundGläser.Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem.1931,203,219−227..
Berthier,L.;Ozawa,M.;Scalliet,C.Configurationalentropyofglass-formingliquids.J. Chem. Phys.2019,150,160902..
Gibbs,J.H.;DiMarzio,E.A.Natureoftheglasstransitionandtheglassystate.J. Chem. Phys.1958,28,373−383..
Flory,P.J.Statisticalthermodynamicsofsemi-flexiblechainmolecules.Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A1956,234,60−73..
DiMarzio,E.A.;Yang,A.J.M.Configurationalentropyapproachtothekineticsofglasses.J. Res. Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol.1997,102,135−157..
Bestul,A.B.;Chang,S.S.Excessentropyatglasstransformation.J. Chem. Phys.1964,40,3731−3733..
Glasstone,S.;Laidler,K.J.;Eyring,H.inThe Theory of Rate Processes: The Kinetics of Chemical Reactions, Viscosity, Diffusion and Electrochemical Phenomena.InternationalChemicalSeries;McGraw-HillBookCompany:Incorporated,1941..
Kauzmann,W.;Eyring,H.TheViscousflowoflargemolecules.J. Am. Chem. Soc.1940,62,3113−3125..
Kincaid,J.F.;Eyring,H.;Stearn,A.E.Thetheoryofabsolutereactionratesanditsapplicationtoviscosityanddiffusionintheliquidstate.Chem. Rev.1941,28,301−365..
Goldstein,M.Viscousliquidsandtheglasstransition:apotentialenergybarrierpicture.J. Chem. Phys.1969,51,3728−3739..
Stillinger,F.H.;Weber,T.A.Hiddenstructureinliquids.Phys. Rev. A1982,25,978−989..
Stillinger,F.H.;Weber,T.A.Packingstructuresandtransitionsinliquidsandsolids.Science1984,225,983−989..
Xu,X.;Douglas,J.F.;Xu,W.S.Influenceofside-chainlengthandrelativerigiditiesofbackboneandsidechainsonglassformationofbranchedpolymers.Macromolecules2021,54,6327−6341..
Xu,X.;Xu,W.S.Meltpropertiesandstringmodeldescriptionofglassformationingraftpolymersofdifferentside-chainlengths.Macromolecules2022,55,3221−3235..
Xu,W.-S.;Douglas,J.F.;Freed,K.F.Generalizedentropytheoryofglass-formationinfullyflexiblepolymermelts.J Chem. Phys.2016,145,234509..
Chen,D.;McKenna,G.B.Deepglassystatedynamicdatachallengeglassmodels:configurationalentropymodels.J. Non-Cryst. Solids2021,566,120871..
Kirkpatrick,T.R.;Wolynes,P.G.Stableandmetastablestatesinmean-fieldPottsandstructuralglasses.Phys. Rev. B1987,36,8552−8564..
Kirkpatrick,T.R.;Thirumalai,D.;Wolynes,P.G.Scalingconceptsforthedynamicsofviscousliquidsnearanidealglassystate.Phys. Rev. A1989,40,1045−1054..
Bouchaud,J.P.;Biroli,G.OntheAdam-Gibbs-Kirkpatrick-Thirumalai-Wolynesscenariofortheviscosityincreaseinglasses.J. Chem. Phys.2004,121,7347−7354..
Lubchenko,V.;Wolynes,P.G.Theoryofstructuralglassesandsupercooledliquids.Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.2007,58,235−266..
Rosenfeld,Y.Relationbetweenthetransportcoefficientsandtheinternalentropyofsimplesystems.Phys. Rev. A1977,15,2545−2549..
Rosenfeld,Y.Aquasi-universalscalinglawforatomictransportinsimplefluids.J. Phys.: Condens. Matter1999,11,5415−5427..
Dyre,J.C.Perspective:excess-entropyscaling.J. Chem. Phys.2018,149,210901..
Weeks,J.D.;Chandler,D.;Andersen,H.C.Roleofrepulsiveforcesindeterminingtheequilibriumstructureofsimpleliquids.J. Chem. Phys.1971,54,5237−5247..
Schweizer,K.S.;Saltzman,E.J.Theoryofdynamicbarriers,activatedhopping,andtheglasstransitioninpolymermelts.J. Chem. Phys.2004,121,1984−2000..
Saltzman,E.J.;Schweizer,K.S.Universalscaling,dynamicfragility,segmentalrelaxation,andvitrificationinpolymermelts.J. Chem. Phys.2004,121,2001−2009..
Chen,K.;Saltzman,E.J.;Schweizer,K.S.Moleculartheoriesofsegmentaldynamicsandmechanicalresponseindeeplysupercooledpolymermeltsandglasses.Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys.2010,1,277−300..
Mirigian,S.;Schweizer,K.S.Elasticallycooperativeactivatedbarrierhoppingtheoryofrelaxationinviscousfluids.I.Generalformulationandapplicationtohardspherefluids.J. Chem. Phys.2014,140,194506..
Mirigian,S.;Schweizer,K.S.Elasticallycooperativeactivatedbarrierhoppingtheoryofrelaxationinviscousfluids.II.Thermalliquids.J. Chem. Phys.2014,140,194507..
Mirigian,S.;Schweizer,K.S.Dynamicaltheoryofsegmentalrelaxationandemergentelasticityinsupercooledpolymermelts.Macromolecules2015,48,1901−1913..
Xie,S.J.;Schweizer,K.S.NonuniversalcouplingofcagescaleHoppingandcollectiveelasticdistortionastheoriginofdynamicfragilitydiversityinglass-formingpolymerliquids.Macromolecules2016,49,9655−9664..
Varotsos,P.;Alexopoulos,K.Decisiveimportanceofthebulkmodulusandtheanharmonicityinthecalculationofmigrationandformationvolumes.Phys. Rev. B1981,24,904−910..
Varotsos,P.;Alexopoulos,K.Calculationofdiffusioncoefficientsatanytemperatureandpressurefromasinglemeasurement.I.Selfdiffusion.Phys. Rev. B1980,22,3130−3134..
Khonik,V.A.;Mitrofanov,Y.P.;Lyakhov,S.A.;Vasiliev,A.N.;Khonik,S.V.;Khoviv,D.A.RelationshipbetweentheshearmodulusG,activationenergy,andshearviscosityηinmetallicglassesbelowandaboveTg:directin situmeasurementsofGandη.Phys. Rev. B2009,79,132204..
Sjögren,L.Temperaturedependenceofviscosityneartheglasstransition.Z. Phys. B-Condensed Matter1990,79,5−13..
Dyre,J.C.Colloquium:Theglasstransitionandelasticmodelsofglass-formingliquids.Rev. Mod. Phys.2006,78,953−972..
Douglas,J.F.;Xu,W.S.Equationofstateandentropytheoryapproachtothermodynamicscalinginpolymericglass-formingliquids.Macromolecules2021,54,3247−3269..
Novikov,V.N.;Sokolov,A.P.Qualitativechangeinstructuraldynamicsofsomeglass-formingsystems.Phys. Rev. E2015,92,062304..
Angell,C.A.Relaxationinliquids,polymersandplasticcrystals-strong/fragilepatternsandproblems.J. Non-Cryst. Solids1991,131-133,13−31..
Angell,C.A.Formationofglassesfromliquidsandbiopolymers.Science1995,267,1924−1935..
Tanaka,H.Anewscenariooftheapparentfragile-to-strongtransitionintetrahedralliquids:waterasanexample.J. Phys.: Condens. Matter2003,15,L703..
Tanaka,H.Bondorientationalorderinliquids:towardsaunifieddescriptionofwater-likeanomalies,liquid-liquidtransition,glasstransition,andcrystallization.Eur. Phys. J. E2012,35,113..
Shi,R.;Russo,J.;Tanaka,H.Originoftheemergentfragile-to-strongtransitioninsupercooledwater.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.2018,115,9444−9449..
Zhang,C.;Hu,L.;Yue,Y.;Mauro,J.C.Fragile-to-strongtransitioninmetallicglass-formingliquids.J. Chem. Phys.2010,133,014508..
Zhang,H.;Wang,X.;Yu,H.B.;Douglas,J.F.Fastdynamicsinamodelmetallicglass-formingmaterial.J. Chem. Phys.2021,154,084505..
Zhang,H.;Wang,X.;Yu,H.B.;Douglas,J.F.Dynamicheterogeneity,cooperativemotion,andJohari-Goldsteinβ-relaxationinametallicglass-formingmaterialexhibitingafragile-to-strongtransition.Eur. Phys. J. E2021,44,56..
Schmidtke,B.;Petzold,N.;Kahlau,R.;Hofmann,M.;Rössler,E.A.Fromboilingpointtoglasstransitiontemperature:transportcoefficientsinmolecularliquidsfollowthree-parameterscaling.Phys. Rev. E2012,86,041507..
Schmidtke,B.;Petzold,N.;Kahlau,R.;;Rössler,E.A.Reorientationaldynamicsinmolecularliquidsasrevealedbydynamiclightscattering:fromboilingpointtoglasstransitiontemperature.J. Chem. Phys.2013,139,084504..
Schmidtke,B.;Hofmann,M.;Lichtinger,A.;Rössler,E.A.Temperaturedependenceofthesegmentalrelaxationtimeofpolymersrevisited.Macromolecules2015,48,3005−3013..
Johari,G.P.;Goldstein,M.Viscousliquidsandtheglasstransition.II.Secondaryrelaxationsinglassesofrigidmolecules.J. Chem. Phys.1970,53,2372−2388..
Johari,G.P.;Goldstein,M.Viscousliquidsandtheglasstransition.III.Secondaryrelaxationsinaliphaticalcoholsandothernonrigidmolecules.J. Chem. Phys.1971,55,4245−4252..
Johari,G.P.Intrinsicmobilityofmolecularglasses.J. Chem. Phys.1973,58,1766−1770..
Xu,W.S.;Douglas,J.F.;Freed,K.F.Influenceofcohesiveenergyonrelaxationinamodelglass-formingpolymermelt.Macromolecules2016,49,8355−8370..
Xu,W.S.;Douglas,J.F.;Freed,K.F.Influenceofpressureonglassformationinasimulatedpolymermelt.Macromolecules2017,50,2585−2598..
Xu,W.S.;Douglas,J.F.;Xu,X.Moleculardynamicsstudyofglassformationinpolymermeltswithvaryingchainstiffness.Macromolecules2020,53,4796−4809..
Wang,X.;Xu,W.-S.;Zhang,H.;Douglas,J.F.Universalnatureofdynamicheterogeneityinglass-formingliquids:acomparativestudyofmetallicandpolymericglass-formingliquids.J. Chem. Phys.2019,151,184503..
Singh,M.;Agarwal,M.;Dhabal,D.;Chakravarty,C.Structuralcorrelationsandcooperativedynamicsinsupercooledliquids.J. Chem. Phys.2012,137,024508..
Banerjee,A.;Sengupta,S.;Sastry,S.;Bhattacharyya,S.M.Roleofstructureandentropyindeterminingdifferencesindynamicsforglassformerswithdifferentinteractionpotentials.Phys. Rev. Lett.2014,113,225701..
Yang,Z.Y.;Nie,W.J.;Liu,L.Y.;Xu,X.L.;Xia,W.J.;Xu,W.S.Applicationsofmachinelearningmethodsinthestudiesofpolymerglassformation.Acta Polymerica Sinica(inChinese)2023,54,432−450..
Cubuk,E.D.;Schoenholz,S.S.;Rieser,J.M.;Malone,B.D.;Rottler,J.;Durian,D.J.;Kaxiras,E.;Liu,A.J.Identifyingstructuralflowdefectsindisorderedsolidsusingmachine-learningmethods.Phys. Rev. Lett.2015,114,108001..
Schoenholz,S.S.;Cubuk,E.D.;Sussman,D.M.;Kaxiras,E.;Liu,A.J.Astructuralapproachtorelaxationinglassyliquids.Nat. Phys.2016,12,469−471..
Cubuk,E.D.;Schoenholz,S.S.;Kaxiras,E.;Liu,A.J.Structuralpropertiesofdefectsinglassyliquids.J. Phys. Chem. B2016,120,6139−6146..
Cubuk,E.D.;Ivancic,R.J.S.;Schoenholz,S.S.;Strickland,D.J.;Basu,A.;Davidson,Z.S.;Fontaine,J.;Hor,J.L.;Huang,Y.R.;Jiang,Y.;Keim,N.C.;Koshigan,K.D.;Lefever,J.A.;Liu,T.;Ma,X.G.;Magagnosc,D.J.;Morrow,E.;Ortiz,C.P.;Rieser,J.M.;Shavit,A.;Still,T.;Xu,Y.;Zhang,Y.;Nordstrom,K.N.;Arratia,P.E.;Carpick,R.W.;Durian,D.J.;Fakhraai,Z.;Jerolmack,D.J.;Lee,D.;Li,J.;Riggleman,R.;Turner,K.T.;Yodh,A.G.;Gianola,D.S.;Liu,A.J.Structure-propertyrelationshipsfromuniversalsignaturesofplasticityindisorderedsolids.Science2017,358,1033−1037..
Boattini,E.;Marín-Aguilar,S.;Mitra,S.;Foffi,G.;Smallenburg,F.;Filion,L.Autonomouslyrevealinghiddenlocalstructuresinsupercooledliquids.Nat. Commun.2020,11,5479..
Boattini,E.;Smallenburg,F.;Filion,L.Averaginglocalstructuretopredictthedynamicpropensityinsupercooledliquids.Phys. Rev. Lett.2021,127,088007..
Alkemade,R.M.;Boattini,E.;Filion,L.;Smallenburg,F.Comparingmachinelearningtechniquesforpredictingglassydynamics.J. Chem. Phys.2022,156,204503..
Bapst,V.;Keck,T.;Grabska-Barwińska,A.;Donner,C.;Cubuk,E.D.;Schoenholz,S.S.;Obika,A.;Nelson,A.W.R.;Back,T.;Hassabis,D.;Kohli,P.Unveilingthepredictivepowerofstaticstructureinglassysystems.Nat. Phys.2020,16,448−454..
Li,H.;Jin,Y.;Jiang,Y.;Chen,J.Z.Y.DeterminingthenonequilibriumcriticalityofaGardnertransitionviaahybridstudyofmolecularsimulationsandmachinelearning.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.2021,118,e2017392118..
Zhang,K.;Li,X.;Jin,Y.;Jiang,Y.Machinelearningglasscagingorderparameterswithanartificialnestedneuralnetwork.Soft Matter2022,18,6270−6277..
0
Views
35
Downloads
0
CSCD
Publicity Resources
Related Articles
Related Author
Related Institution